Smart city : hop,skip : how smart is Pune?
Chalke, Neeta Ed.
Smart city : hop,skip : how smart is Pune? - Pune Maharashtra social housing & action league 2020 - 211p.
Contents
Foreword IV W Deshpande. President. MASHAL 7
Executive Summary 9
Section 1: Background 15
1.1 lndian Urban context 17
1.2 Smart Urbanism 18
1.3 Smart Urbanism in India [GOl/official perspective) 18
1.4 Pune Smart City 24
Section 2: Methodology 47
2.1 Aims and Objectives 49
2.2 Desk Research 52
2.3 Field Research 52
2.4 Reflections and limitation 55
2.5 Working with the City Coalition 57
Section 3: Survey Finding and Analysis 67
3.1 ICT. Developrnent and the city 63
3.2 Profile of Respondents in the ABD area 65
3.3 Understanding the Citizens· Perception o~ the SCM 66
3.3.1 Awareness of the SCM and its Implementation 67
3.3.2 Engagement in the SCM 69
3.3.3 Citizens· Opinion of the SCM in Pune 71
3.3.4 Citizens' Perspective on Implementation of Projects in ABO 76
3.4 'No Response· as a Response : Patterns of Silence 83
3.5 ls the SCM representing Citizens· Needs and Aspirations? 83
Section 4: The Voices of Stakeholders on the Smart City Mission
and the Emerging Concerns 85
4.1 lnterviews with Stakeholders of the Smart City 116
4.2 Emerging Concerns 116
4.2.1 Community Participation 116
4.2.2 Citizen Awareness 116
Li.2.3 Governance 117
4.2.4 Transparency 117
4.2.5 Role of Technology 117
4.2.6 Sustainability 117
4.2.7 Efficiency 119
4.2.8 lnclusivity 119
Section 5: Multi-disciplinary Perspectives on the Smart City Mission 133
5.1 Smart Ci ties or World Class Cities? IDunu Roy 135
5.2 The Smart City in a Global Perspective I Sulakshana Mahajan 143
5.3 Smart Sustainable Cities: The First Principles I Or. Gurudas Nulkar 151
5.4 An Analysis of the Financial Robustness and Sustainability
of the Smart Cities Mission I Dr. Ravikant Joshi 157
5.5 The Politics of Implementation I Vijay Kumbhare 178
Section 6: Conclusion and lessons 185
6.1 Can Inclusivity be more than just an idea? 187
6.2 ICT as a Utility not a status symbol 189
6.3 Collaboration VS. Corporatisation 191
6.4 Urban Development as a social Good? 194
6.5 Lessons 195
References 199
Acknowledgements 202
Our Contributors 203
List of Abbreviations 205
List of Figures 206
List of Tables 207
307.76 / CHA
Smart city : hop,skip : how smart is Pune? - Pune Maharashtra social housing & action league 2020 - 211p.
Contents
Foreword IV W Deshpande. President. MASHAL 7
Executive Summary 9
Section 1: Background 15
1.1 lndian Urban context 17
1.2 Smart Urbanism 18
1.3 Smart Urbanism in India [GOl/official perspective) 18
1.4 Pune Smart City 24
Section 2: Methodology 47
2.1 Aims and Objectives 49
2.2 Desk Research 52
2.3 Field Research 52
2.4 Reflections and limitation 55
2.5 Working with the City Coalition 57
Section 3: Survey Finding and Analysis 67
3.1 ICT. Developrnent and the city 63
3.2 Profile of Respondents in the ABD area 65
3.3 Understanding the Citizens· Perception o~ the SCM 66
3.3.1 Awareness of the SCM and its Implementation 67
3.3.2 Engagement in the SCM 69
3.3.3 Citizens· Opinion of the SCM in Pune 71
3.3.4 Citizens' Perspective on Implementation of Projects in ABO 76
3.4 'No Response· as a Response : Patterns of Silence 83
3.5 ls the SCM representing Citizens· Needs and Aspirations? 83
Section 4: The Voices of Stakeholders on the Smart City Mission
and the Emerging Concerns 85
4.1 lnterviews with Stakeholders of the Smart City 116
4.2 Emerging Concerns 116
4.2.1 Community Participation 116
4.2.2 Citizen Awareness 116
Li.2.3 Governance 117
4.2.4 Transparency 117
4.2.5 Role of Technology 117
4.2.6 Sustainability 117
4.2.7 Efficiency 119
4.2.8 lnclusivity 119
Section 5: Multi-disciplinary Perspectives on the Smart City Mission 133
5.1 Smart Ci ties or World Class Cities? IDunu Roy 135
5.2 The Smart City in a Global Perspective I Sulakshana Mahajan 143
5.3 Smart Sustainable Cities: The First Principles I Or. Gurudas Nulkar 151
5.4 An Analysis of the Financial Robustness and Sustainability
of the Smart Cities Mission I Dr. Ravikant Joshi 157
5.5 The Politics of Implementation I Vijay Kumbhare 178
Section 6: Conclusion and lessons 185
6.1 Can Inclusivity be more than just an idea? 187
6.2 ICT as a Utility not a status symbol 189
6.3 Collaboration VS. Corporatisation 191
6.4 Urban Development as a social Good? 194
6.5 Lessons 195
References 199
Acknowledgements 202
Our Contributors 203
List of Abbreviations 205
List of Figures 206
List of Tables 207
307.76 / CHA